BIDS CONTRACTING
AnalysisTeardownsProjectsAboutStart a consult

Large projects, on average, overrun their budgets and schedules by 30 to 45 percent. Those are the well-funded, professionally staffed ones. A thin-margin residential deal, with a builder you picked on price, is not safer — it’s the same risk with less cushion under it. On an out-of-state investment property, the general contractor is the single biggest variable in your return, and the one you can watch the least. So you vet the builder like the whole deal depends on it. It does.

You’re not vetting a price. You’re vetting whether he can hold one.

The lowest bid is usually the highest risk — it’s the number most likely to grow. And watch the word “standard.” When a builder says “standard finishes” or “standard spec,” that word means nothing until you make him define it, line by line. Standard is not a scope. It’s a blank he fills in later, on your dime.

A client of ours learned that on his first build, with another builder, before he came to us. The “spec” package he was sold included exactly one can light in a fifteen-hundred-square-foot kitchen. The job finished seventy-five percent over budget and nine months later than promised. None of that surprised the builder. It surprised the client — because he signed before the scope was real.

If a builder can’t price out exactly what you want, don’t put ink on paper until you know the cost. Every light, every finish, every allowance — named and priced. A number you can’t see behind is a number that grows.

The questions that separate the two.

Ask these before you sign anything. The answers — and how fast they come — tell you almost everything.

01
Do they build your product, over and over?
A builder who has delivered your exact product a few hundred times prices from memory and manages from muscle. A first-timer prices from hope, and you fund the education.
02
Will they show actuals, not just a bid?
Ask for real cost history on finished jobs, not a fresh estimate. A builder who tracks actuals can tell you where every number came from. One who can’t is guessing with your money.
03
Will they price your exact scope?
Every light, every finish, in writing — not “standard.” If they can’t or won’t itemize what you actually want, that reluctance is your answer.
04
Can they prove a timeline?
Anyone can say “about four months.” Ask for permit-to-keys actuals on the last ten jobs. Discipline shows up as a tight range, not a wide one.
05
What is their change-order process?
Overruns live here. Ask exactly how a change gets priced, approved, and communicated before work proceeds. A vague answer is a preview of your budget.
06
How do they report — checklists, books, budget? Ask for a sample.
Ask how often you get a written checklist and a current budget-to-actual, and then ask to see a real one from a live job. A builder who runs the job by the numbers can hand you a sample in a minute. A builder who can’t is running it by feel.
07
How often are they on the job — and how often will you hear from them?
Boots on the site and a scheduling update on a set cadence. A builder who walks the job weekly and updates you weekly is running it. One who shows up to close the deal and disappears is not.
08
Do they control their subs, or chase them?
A deep, loyal trade bench is why a schedule holds. Ask who frames, pours, and roofs for them — and how long those crews have run with them.
09
Do they manage, or just build?
Scheduling, procurement, quality control, draw management, reporting — that’s the job behind the job. If the answer is “we just build great houses,” you’re the project manager now, from another state.
10
Will they show you a job in progress?
Finished photos are staged. Ask to walk an active site. How it looks mid-build — orderly or chaotic — is how yours will run.
11
Do they think in your math?
A builder who understands yield on cost, not just cost per foot, is underwriting the same deal you are. That alignment is worth more than a low bid.
And don’t be sold by the software. A project-management app is only as good as the people using it — and plenty of builders buy one to win the pitch, not to run the job. Ask to see it filled out on a real, current project. Empty screens and stale updates tell you everything.

Know which contract you’re signing.

The contract type decides who carries the risk. Three you’ll run into:

Cost-plus (fee or percentage)You pay the actual cost plus the builder’s fee. Transparent — but the builder carries little of the overrun, and a percentage fee quietly rewards a bigger number. Fine with a builder you trust; expensive with one you don’t.
Not-to-exceed / guaranteed maxThe builder commits to a ceiling and eats the overage above it. More risk on him, more certainty for you. This is where a confident builder puts his money where his estimate is.
Fixed / set priceOne number for a defined scope. The cleanest certainty you can get — but only as good as the scope behind it. Fixed price on a fuzzy scope is the can light all over again.

Then ask the question most builders would rather you didn’t: what will you put at risk if you miss the schedule or the budget you agreed to? A builder willing to carry a penalty for missing his own benchmarks is telling you he believes them. One who won’t carry any risk is telling you something too.

The contract is where confidence becomes commitment. A builder sure of his number will stand behind it in writing. Ask him to.

If you’re not local, add three.

Distance is where a weak builder hides and a strong one earns the premium. Before you commit from out of town, get straight answers on three more: who is your single point of contact, how often you get a real update with dated photos, and how draws are tied to actual completion instead of the calendar. The best builders make distance a non-issue, because the reporting is that good. The worst make you buy a plane ticket to find out what’s wrong.

You can’t manage what you can’t see. So you buy a builder whose reporting does the seeing for you.

Overkill, until the one time it isn’t.

Vetting a builder this hard feels like too much right up until the deal where it would have saved you. The market can be perfect, the lot can be cheap, the rent can be real — and the whole thing can still die in the build. That is exactly why you do this before you wire a dollar, not after.

The numbers are real. Whether a deal holds is another question. A strong pro forma in the wrong hands still loses money — and seeing the trouble before it starts is the part no spreadsheet gives you. That’s the job.
Vetting a builder for a Wichita deal? Start a consult 15 minutes. Bring a lot or a deal. No pitch.
How this is sourced. The 30-to-45-percent overrun figure is McKinsey’s survey of large-project executives, linked above. The scope, reporting, contract, and delivery practices described are Bids Contracting’s own first-party experience; the cautionary example is anonymized — no client, builder, or project is identifiable.
Sources: McKinsey — Increasing transparency in megaproject execution · Bids Contracting — Wichita build-cost benchmarks
Bids Contracting LLC · General Contractor & Developer · Wichita, KSEST. WICHITA